Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christina Van Dyke's avatar

This is so exciting! I’ve written a book with OUP (A Hidden Wisdom: Self-Knowledge, Reason, Love, Persons, and Immortality) that looks at the philosophical aspect of writings of medieval women like Hadewijch, Marguerite Porete, Catherine of Siena, and Julian of Norwich’s, and I love that the contributions of medieval women are increasingly getting their due - and in their own words!

Expand full comment
CGesange's avatar

Re: Joan of Arc: dozens of eyewitnesses said she was executed by a pro-English tribunal because she had opposed the English government, not for the reason this article claims ("daring to step forward and challenge medieval societal norms") since she didn't do that: she denied fighting or calling herself a commander, confirmed by numerous eyewitness accounts, and she had already been previously approved by high-ranking clergy at Poitiers in April 1429 (after Charles VII had her examined for orthodoxy) which included the Inquisitor for Southern France. She was a religious visionary in an era when many women and girls had been accepted in that role, so her role did not violate societal norms. The English also executed a boy named Guillaume le Berger for opposing them, so it had nothing to do with gender. Additionally, her signature is "Jehanne" rather than "Jehann" as this article says: if you look closely you can see an 'e' at the end, which is clearler in her other two signatures on other letters. If anyone wants to see the full translation of the letter in the exhibit, here's an online translation : https://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_letter_Nov1429.html

That site also has translations of all of her other surviving letters: https://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_letters.html

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts